Life

The war between Michigan and Ohio

The mouth of the Maumee River at Toledo on Lake Erie was the prize in the 1835 war between Ohio and the Michigan Territory. 

By Tom Jones / Special to The Detroit News

President Andrew Jackson

It was a “war” that both Ohio and Michigan could rightfully claim they won, a one-casualty conflict in which the only blood drawn came from a knife thrust into the leg of a Michigan sheriff.

It was the Toledo War, a hotly contentious boundary dispute when it began in April, 1835, but now a source of amusement to many whose only knowledge of the war is from flawed accounts of the event.

Historian Tom Jones

Most ask why anyone would fight Ohio over Toledo — especially since Michigan got the Upper Peninsula as consolation for losing the argument.

The late Tom Jones, former director of the Historical Society of Michigan, called that a “common, hindsight reaction built on a misconception. It ignores a couple of points.”

First, Toledo as a significant entity didn’t exist in 1835. And second, when the boundary arguement was settled, Michigan didn’t get the Upper Peninsula in exchange, it got only the western end of the peninsula — the eastern end had long been considered part of Michigan, Jones said.

In 1835 Ohio had been a state since 1803. The Michigan territory’s population numberted only about 6,000. Ohioans, who thought of the territory as unclaimed wilderness that they could more or less annex at will, claimed their boundary ran along a line north of the Maumee River. That assured Ohioans in the region of access to Lake Erie, an obviously important consideration.

The claim conflicted with Congresssional guidelines for carving up the western lands as established in the Northwest Ordinance of 1787. But who really cared?

But as the population of the Michigan territory grew, its officials also perceived the advantages of controlling the mouth of the Maumee. Plus, they had legal ground for this claim. It seemed quite clear that according to the Northwest Ordinance the boundary should be drawn from the tip of Lake Michigan eastward to Lake Erie, which would put the mouth of the Maumee in Michigan.

Stevens T. Mason, governor of Michigan Territory

When Michigan petitioned to become a state in 1835, Ohio began putting pressure on Congress in support of its claim to a boundary line extending to North Cape in Maumee Bay. Michigan objected. Ohio insisted.

During the dispute, confusion reigned. People addressing letters to villages in the disputed territory sometimes gave the address as Ohio, sometimes as Michigan. At least one letter was addressed to someone in the “State of Confusion.”

“As with all such matters, the issue wasn’t simple. It involved presidential politics, party alliances, poor maps, pride, and more,” says Jones.

“I contend that the solution was political,” he said. “Had the matter gone to the Supreme Court, it probably would have been resolved in Michigan’s favor. But President (Andrew) Jackson didn’t want that. The year 1836 was an election year. He was courting Ohio’s electoral votes, and he worked out a political compromise.”

But before that could be reached, the war began.

In February, Ohio’s legislature voted to extend the state’s jurisdiction over the Toledo Strip. Michigan Territory Gov. Stevens T. Mason responded that he would not hesitate “to resist to the utmost every encroachment or invasion upon the rights and soil of this territory.”

Ohio Gov. Robert Lucas, calling Mason’s supposed bluff, showed up at Perrysburg, Ohio, along with 300 Ohio militiamen. Meanwhile, Gov. Mason marched to Monroe from Detroit, the territorial capital, with a “posse” of sheriff’s deputies, who actually were Michigan militiamen.

“Men galloping about–guns getting ready–wagons being filled with people and hurrying off, and everybody in commotion. The two armies struggled for a soggy week to find each other in the wilderness and swamps surrounding the region, but never did come in contact.”

When elements from Michigan and Ohio did meet, however, Michigan started the shooting. President Jackson had asked Gov. Mason to let Ohio commissioners run a survey of the disputed boundary line to just north of the Point Place. Gov. Mason refused.

Ohio Gov. Robert Lucas

When Gov. Lucas sent his surveyors out on April 26, a Michigan posse under Lenawee County Undersheriff William McNair met them. The undersheriff demanded that the Ohioans leave Michigan territory. They refused and shots were fired.

No one was hit. But members of the surveying crew were arrested and charged with violating the Pains and Penalties Act, which prohibited Ohioans from exercising any authority in Michigan.

Under Gov. Mason’s orders, Gen. Jacob. W. Brown of Tecumseh combed the disputed territory, arresting Ohio officials, including the entire family of Maj. Benjamin Franklin Stickney. The Major was tied to his horse for the trip to the Monroe County Jail.

Maj. Stickney’s son, named Two (he had a brother named One), made a dramatic attempt to rescue his father by drawing a knife and lunging at Monroe County Sheriff Joseph Wood, wounding him in the thigh and drawing the only blood in the Toledo War.

Congress eventually approved a bill admitting Michigan to statehood on the condition that it accept the northern boundary line, which effectively ended the matter. Or so everyone thought. As recently as 1972, the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments from attorneys who still maintain that Toledo belongs in Michigan. But most Toledo War buffs consider that a footnote to the affair.

 

A plaque dedicated in 1967 marks the spot in Ann Arbor where delegates met to consider the proposal by Congress that ended the conflict between Michigan and Ohio.From left are State Rep. Roy Smith of Ypsilanti, Jen Cotter of Elyria, Ohio, and Terry Pray of Charlotte, Mich. Cotter and Pray are descendants of participants in the assembly.